The United Nations Plan for
Political Accommodation
B
enan Sevan, Diego Cordovez' successor as special representative of the
UN secretary general, attempted to apply a political formula that had
been announced by UN Secretary General Javier Perez De Cuellar on May
21, 1991. Referred to as a five-point plan, it included: recognition of
Afghanistan's sovereign status as a politically non-aligned Islamic
state; acceptance of the right of Afghans to self-determination in
choosing their form of government and social and economic systems; need
for a transitional period permitting a dialogue between Afghans leading
to establishment of a government with widely based support; the
termination of all foreign arms deliveries into Afghanistan; funding
from the international community adequate to support the return of
Afghanistan's refugees and its reconstruction from the devastation of
war.
These principles were endorsed by the Soviet Union and the United
States and Afghanistan's neighboring governments, but there was no
military means of enforcing it. The three moderate Peshawar parties
accepted it, but it was opposed by Hekmatyar, Rabbani, Sayyaf and Khalis
who held out for a total victory over the Kabul government.
Nevertheless, these four "fundamentalists" found it politic to
participate in the effort to implement the UN initiative. Pressure from
their foreign supporters and the opportunities that participation
offered to modify or obstruct the plan encouraged them to be reluctant
players. Pakistan and Iran worked jointly to win mujahidin acceptance at
a conference in July, 1991. Indicating its formal acceptance of the
plan, Pakistan officially announced the termination of its own military
assistance to the resistance in late January 1992. Najibullah also
declared his acceptance, but until March 18, 1992, he hedged the
question of whether or when he would resign in the course of
negotiations.
Sevan made a strenuous effort to create the mechanism for the
dialogue that would lead to installation of the transitional process
envisaged in point three of the plan. The contemplated arrangement was a
refinement and a simplification of earlier plans which had been built
around the possible participation of Zahir Shah and the convoking of a
meeting in the Loya Jirgah tradition. By March 1992 the plan had evolved
to the holding of a meeting in Europe of some 150 respected Afghans
representing all communities in the late spring. Most of Sevan's effort
was directed at winning the cooperation of all the Afghan protagonists,
including the Shia parties in control of the Hazarajat. In early
February, he appeared to have won the active support of commanders among
the Pushtuns in eastern Afghanistan and acquiescence from Rabbani and
Hekmatyar to the extent of submitting lists of participants acceptable
to them in the proposed meeting. Simultaneously, Sevan labored to
persuade Najibullah to step down on the presumption that his removal
would bring about full mujahidin participation. Instead, Najibullah's
March 18 announcement accelerated the collapse of his government. This
collapse in turn triggered events that moved faster than Sevan's plan
could be put into effect.
In the midst of hectic maneuvering to put the European meeting
together, Sevan declared on April 4 that most of the parties (including
Hekmatyar's) and the Kabul government had agreed to transfer power to a
proposed transitional authority. He also announced the creation of a
"pre-transition council" to take control of government "perhaps within
the next two weeks." He was struggling to keep up with events which
threatened to dissolve the government before he had a replacement for
it.
In the end, some of the Shia parties and the Islamists in Peshawar
blocked his scheme. They withheld their choices or submitted candidates
for the European meeting whom they knew would be unacceptable to others.
The hope for a neutral, comprehensive approach to a political settlement
among Afghans was dashed. Sevan then worked to ensure a peaceful
turnover of power from the interim Kabul government which replaced
Najibullah on April 18 to the forces of Massoud and Dostam. In effect,
the turnover was peaceful, but without an overall political settlement
in place. Within a week a new civil war would begin among the victors.
The Islamic Republic of
Afghanistan, Since 1992
Mujahidin victory was the result of the vacuum created by the implosion
of Marxism-Leninism in Moscow and Kabul. The victors have perpetuated
that vacuum by failing to find a common approach to government or a
formula for sharing power among themselves. Their jihad experience
committed them to attempt to create a political innovation for
Afghanistan--an Islamic Republic, inspired by the revolution in Iran,
but clearly to be different in structure and doctrine. Tragically, on
the day the Peshawar parties reached a tentative agreement on how they
would establish their Islamic republic, a new war for Kabul began.
The Peshawar Accord,
April 25, 1992
By April 25, Massoud could no longer wait for an agreement by the
Peshawar parties on arrangements for a new government. With the
cooperation of Pushtun officials in the army and the interior ministry,
Hekmatyar's troops were infiltrating Kabul. The situation appeared to
offer the opportunity for him to take power in a sudden stroke, but his
move was too late and too weak. Dostam's and Massoud's forces were
better positioned and stronger. After two days of hard fighting
Hekmatyar and his Khalqi allies were forced out of the city. A new
struggle for power had begun.
For the moment Massoud had handed the
Peshawar parties a virtual fait accompli, Kabul was theirs. He awaited
their takeover of government. Although real power was being handed to
them, the parties had reached no understanding on how they wished to
govern. Under Pakistani guidance and some pressure they hastily agreed
to rule through a leadership council and an interim presidency. This was
to assure residual powers for themselves as party leaders. They gave no
consideration to dissolving their parties now that their function of
leading a war against communists was fulfilled.
The council--whose role paralleled that of the PDPA's Revolutionary
Council--was to be made up of party staffers who in many instances were
relatives of the leaders. A succession of interim presidents was named.
Mujaddidi was to serve from April 28 to June 28, 1992. Rabbani then was
to succeed him and serve until October 28. Between them they were to
prepare a provisional constitution for the Islamic republic, which was
to be ratified by a national shura later in the year. Meanwhile, the
parties would share among themselves appointments to the cabinet, with
Hekmatyar given the choice of becoming Prime Minister. Arrangements for
actual government mirrored the distribution of power they had created
for their shadow government in Peshawar. Its functions were paralyzed
from the beginning while the contenders for total power maneuvered for
advantage.