The divided PDPA succeeded the Daoud regime with a new government under the
leadership of Nur Muhammad Taraki of the Khalq faction. In 1967 the PDPA
had split into two groups--Khalq and Parcham--but ten years later, the
efforts of the Soviet Union had brought the factions back together,
however unstable the merger.
A critical assessment of the period
between the Saur (April) Revolution of 1978 and the complete withdrawal
of Soviet troops in February 1989 requires analysis of three different,
yet closely intertwined, series of events: those within the PDPA
government of Afghanistan; those involving the mujahidin ("holy
warriors") who fought the communist regime in Kabul from bases in
Pakistan, Iran, and Afghanistan; and those concerning the Soviet Union's
invasion in December 1979 and withdrawal nine years later.
In Kabul, the initial cabinet appeared to be carefully constructed to
alternate ranking positions between Khalqis and Parchamis: Taraki was
prime minister, Karmal was senior deputy prime minister, and Hafizullah
Amin of Khalq was foreign minister. In early July, however, the Khalqi
purge of Parchamis began with Karmal dispatched to Czechoslovakia as
ambassador (along with others shipped out of the country). Amin appeared
to be the principal beneficiary of this strategy, since he now ranked
second, behind Taraki. The regime also issued a series of decrees, many
of which were viewed by conservatives as opposing Islam, including one
declaring the equality of the sexes. Land reform was decreed, as was a
prohibition on usury.
Internal rebellion against the regime began in Afghanistan in the
summer and fall of 1978. A number of attempts by Parchamis to oust the
Khalqis were reported. The intense rivalry between Taraki and Amin
within the Khalq faction heated up, culminating in the death--admittedly
the murder--of Taraki. In September 1979, Taraki's followers, with
Soviet complicity, had made several attempts on Amin's life. The final
attempt backfired, however, and it was Taraki who was eliminated and
Amin, who assumed power in Afghanistan. The Soviets had at first backed
Amin, but they realized that he was too rigidly Marxist-Leninist to
survive politically in a country as conservative and religious as
Afghanistan.
Taraki's death was first noted in the Kabul Times on 10 October and
reported that the former leader only recently hailed as the "great
teacher...great genius...great leader" had died quietly "of serious
illness, which he had been suffering for some time." Less than three
months later, after the Amin government had been overthrown, the newly
installed followers of Babrak Karmal gave another account of Taraki's
death. According to this account, Amin ordered the commander of the
palace guard to have Taraki executed. Taraki reportedly was suffocated
with a pillow over his head. Amin's emergence from the power struggle
within the small divided communist party in Afghanistan alarmed the
Soviet and would usher in the series of events which lead to the Soviet
invasion.
During this period, many Afghans fled to Pakistan and Iran and began
organizing a resistance movement to the "atheistic" and "infidel"
communist regime backed by the Soviets. Although the groups organizing
in the Pakistani city of Peshawar would later, after the Soviet
invasion, be described by the western press as "freedom fighters"--as if
their goal were to establish a representative democracy in
Afghanistan--in reality these groups each had agendas of their own that
were often far from democratic.
Outside observers usually identify the two warring groups as
"fundamentalists" and "traditionalists." Rivalries between these groups
continued during the Afghan civil war that followed the Soviet
withdrawal. The rivalries of these groups brought the plight of the
Afghans to the attention of the West, and it was they who received
military assistance from the United States and a number of other
nations.
The fundamentalists based their organizing principle around mass
politics and included several divisions of the Jamiat-i-Islami. The
leader of the parent branch, Burhanuddin Rabbani, began organizing in
Kabul before repression of religious conservatives, which began in 1974,
forced him to flee to Pakistan during Daoud's regime. Perhaps best known
among the leaders was Gulbaddin Hikmatyar, who broke with Rabbani to
form another resistance group, the Hizb-e-Islami, which became
Pakistan's favored arms recipient. Another split, engineered by Yunus
Khales, resulted in a second group using the name Hizb-e-Islami--a group
that was somewhat more moderate than Hikmatyar's. A fourth
fundamentalist group was the Ittehad-i-Islami led by Rasool Sayyaf.
Rabbani's group received its greatest support from northern Afghanistan
where the best known resistance commander in Afghanistan--Ahmad Shah
Massoud--a Tajik, like Rabbani, operated against the Soviets with
considerable success.
The organizing principles of traditionalist groups differed from
those of the fundamentalists. Formed from loose ties among ulama
in Afghanistan, the traditionalist leaders were not concerned, unlike
fundamentalists, with redefining Islam in Afghan society but instead
focused on the use of the sharia as the source of law
(interpreting the sharia is a principal role of the ulama).
Among the three groups in Peshawar, the most important was the
Jebh-e-Nejat-e-Milli led by Sibghatullah Mojadeddi. Some of the
traditionalists were willing to accept restoration of the monarchy and
looked to former King Zahir Shah, exiled in Italy, as the ruler.
Other ties also were important in holding together some resistance
groups. Among these were links within sufi orders, such as the
Mahaz-e-Milli Islami, one of the traditionalist groups associated with
the Gilani sufi order led by Pir Sayyid Gilani. Another group,
the Shia Muslims of Hazarajat, organized the refugees in Iran.
In Kabul, Amin's ascension to the top position was quick. The Soviets
had a hand in Taraki's attempts on Amin's life and were not pleased with
his rise. Amin began unfinished attempts to moderate what many Afghans
viewed as an anti-Islam regime. Promising more religious freedom,
repairing mosques, presenting copies of the Koran to religious groups,
invoking the name of Allah in his speeches, and declaring that the Saur
Revolution was "totally based on the principles of Islam." Yet many
Afghans held Amin responsible for the regime's harshest measures and the
Soviets, worried about their huge investment in Afghanistan might be
jeopardized, increased the number of "advisers" in Afghanistan. Amin
become the target of several assassination attempts in early and
mid-December 1979.
The Soviets began their invasion of Afghanistan on December 25, 1979.
Within two days, they had secured Kabul, deploying a special Soviet
assault unit against Darulaman Palace, where elements of the Afghan army
loyal to Amin put up a fierce, but brief resistance. With Amin's death
at the palace, Babrak Karmal, exiled leader of the Parcham faction of
the PDPA was installed by the Soviets as Afghanistan's new head of
government.
A number of theories have been advanced for the Soviet action. These
interpretations of Soviet motives do not always agree--what is known for
certain is that the decision was influenced by many factors--that in
Brezhnev's words the decision to invade Afghanistan was truly "was no
simple decision." Two factors were certain to have figured heavily in
Soviet calculations. The Soviet Union, always interested in establishing
a cordon sanitaire of subservient or neutral states on its
frontiers, was increasingly alarmed at the unstable, unpredictable
situation on its southern border. Perhaps as important, the Brezhnev
doctrine declared that the Soviet Union had a "right" to come to the
assistance of an endangered fellow socialist country. Presumably
Afghanistan was a friendly regime that could not survive against growing
pressure from the resistance without direct assistance from the Soviet
Union.
Whatever the Soviet goals may have been, the international response
was sharp and swift. United States President Jimmy Carter, reassessing
the strategic situation in his State of the Union address in January,
1980, identified Pakistan as a "front-line state" in the global struggle
against communism. He reversed his stand of a year earlier that aid to
Pakistan be terminated as a result of its nuclear program and offered
Pakistan a military and economic assistance package if it would act as a
conduit for United States and other assistance to the mujahidin.
Pakistani president Zia ul-Haq refused Carter's package but later a
larger aid offer from the Reagan administration was accepted. Questions
about Pakistan's nuclear program were, for the time being, set aside.
Assistance also came from China, Egypt, and Saudi Arabia. Also forth
coming was international aid to help Pakistan deal with more than 3
million fleeing Afghan refugees.
The Soviets grossly underestimated the huge cost of the Afghan
venture--described, in time, as the Soviet Union's Vietnam--to their
state. International opposition also became increasingly vocal. The
foreign ministers of the Organization of the Islamic Conference deplored
the invasion and demanded Soviet withdrawal at a meeting in Islamabad in
January 1980. Action by the United Nations (UN) Security Council was
impossible because the Soviets were armed with veto power, but the UN
General Assembly regularly passed resolutions opposing the Soviet
occupation.
Pakistan proposed talks among the countries directly involved and,
although they did not meet, Pakistan and Afghanistan began "proximity"
talks in June 1982 through UN official Diego Cordovez. Although these
sessions continued for a seemingly interminable length of time--joined
by the Soviet Union and the United States--they eventually resulted in
an agreement on Soviet withdrawal from Afghanistan.
Other events outside Afghanistan, especially in the Soviet Union,
contributed to the eventual agreement. The toll in casualties, economic
resources, and loss of support at home increasingly felt in the Soviet
Union was causing criticism of the occupation policy. Brezhnev died in
1982, and after two short-lived successors, Mikhail Gorbachev assumed
leadership in March 1985. As Gorbachev opened up the country's system,
it became more clear that the Soviet Union wished to find a face-saving
way to withdraw from Afghanistan.
The civil war in Afghanistan was guerrilla warfare and a war of
attrition between the several communist (that is, PDPA) controlled
regimes and the mujahidin; it cost both sides a great deal.
Many Afghans, perhaps as many as five million, or one-quarter of the
country's population, fled to Pakistan and Iran where they organized
into guerrilla groups to strike Soviet and government forces inside
Afghanistan. Others remained in Afghanistan and also formed fighting
groups; perhaps most notable was one led by Ahmad Shah Massoud in the
northeastern part of Afghanistan. These various groups were supplied
with funds to purchase arms, principally from the United States, Saudi
Arabia, China, and Egypt. Despite high casualties on both sides,
pressure continued to mount on the Soviet Union, especially after the
United States brought in Stinger anti-aircraft missiles which severely
reduced the effectiveness of Soviet air cover.
The effects of the civil war and Soviet invasion had an impact well
beyond Afghanistan's boundaries. Most observers consider Afghanistan a
major step along the road to the eventual dissolution of the Soviet
Union.
Meanwhile, a change had taken place in Kabul. On May 4, 1986, Karmal
resigned as secretary general of the PDPA and was replaced by Najibullah.
Karmal retained the presidency for a while, but power had shifted to
Najibullah, who had previously headed the State Information Service (Khadamate
Ettelaate Dowlati--KHAD), the Afghan secret service agency. Najibullah
tried to diminish differences with the resistance and appeared prepared
to allow Islam a greater role as well as legalize opposition groups, but
any moves he made toward concessions were rejected out of hand by the
mujahidin.
Proximity talks in Geneva continued, and on April 14, 1988, Pakistan
and Afghanistan reached an agreement providing for the withdrawal of
Soviet troops from Afghanistan in nine months, the creation of a neutral
Afghan state, and the repatriation of the Afghan refugees. The United
States and the Soviet Union would act as guarantors of the agreement.
The treaty was less well-received by many mujahidin groups who
demanded Najibullah's departure as the price for advising their refugee
followers to return to Afghanistan.
Nevertheless, the agreement on withdrawal held, and on February 15,
1989, the last Soviet troops departed on schedule from Afghanistan.
Their exit, however, did not bring either lasting peace or resettlement,
as Afghanistan went from one civil war to another.
An indispensable book for exploring Afghan history is Louis Dupree's
monumental work, Afghanistan, which includes a wealth of
information from the point of view of a scholar who spent many years in
the country. The foremost British history of Afghanistan, W. Kerr
Fraser-Tytler's book, Afghanistan: A Study of Political Developments
in Central and Southern Asia, written from the perspective of years
spent in the region, has valuable insights into all periods of Afghan
history but especially the nineteenth century. Arnold Charles Fletcher's
Afghanistan: Highway of Conquest also provides useful insights.
In the twentieth century, more detailed studies of specific sub periods
have been recorded. Leon B. Poullada's Reform and Rebellion in
Afghanistan, 1919-1929 is a fascinating and well-written scholarly
study of King Amanullah's reign that also includes insights applicable
to other periods of Afghan history. (For further information and
complete citations, see Bibliography